Chapter Text
They didn’t tell the boys about their arrangement on their camping trip. They decided to wait a little while longer. Until the lease on the apartment Gary lived in with Art was up. Gary had told him months in advance he was planning on moving and Hank, tired of living with his parents because it was a total cockblock was going to be moving into his room. Harkness was gonna take Pete’s room and Ray, was finally going to be moving out of his childhood home.
Collie and Gary were going to move in with Stebbins and tell their friends at a small party at their new place. They had no idea Collie was moving in, they thought that Gary was going to be staying in the extra bedroom but that obviously wasn’t true.
“I don’t wanna be the one talking,” Gary said as he tweaked out in front of their bedroom mirror. He was messing with his hair, unhappily moving it around, combing it then messing it up again. He was wearing jeans, a shirt with the sleeves cut off, and one of Stebbins' flannels.
“You won’t be,” Collie said as he lit a cigarette from Stebbins' bed.
“I am so not getting my deposit back,” Stebbins said as he buttoned up his short-sleeve dress shirt.
Collie shrugged. “Hopefully we never have to move.”
Stebbins smiled at his usage of the term we.
“Is there something wrong with this mirror?” Gary asked in a paranoid tone.
“No.”
“No.”
Stebbins and Collie replied in unison.
Stebbins walked over to Gary and wrapped his body around his waist from behind. “You’ll be okay.”
Gary’s eyes met his in the mirror and he pouted. “Fuck me after they leave?”
Collie laughed. “You’re insatiable.”
“Will do.”
“What do you have to worry about?” Stebbins asked against his neck.
Gary shrugged.
“They already know you’re gay,” Collie called out.
“You think they’ll think this is weird? The whole three people thing?”
“Who cares?” Collie asked.
“Maybe.” Stebbins kissed the back of Gary’s head. “But we’ll explain it. They’re our friends.“
“Them knowing won’t change anything?” Gary asked, skittishly.
“Turn around.”
Gary closed his eyes, scrunched up his face, and turned to face Stebbins.
“Open your eyes.”
Gary waited another moment before he listened. He opened his eyes and looked up at Stebbins.
“Nothing anyone says will have any bearing on our relationship. You understand?”
Gary nodded.
Stebbins leaned in and kissed him sweetly. “I asked you to move in with me because I see a future here, because you make me happy.”
“You make me happy too.”
“You guys wanna go get the food or greet the guests?”
Gary looked at Collie.
“Food,” Collie said immediately.
Gary nodded.
Collie stood up, put his cigarette out in the ashtray beside their bed, and grabbed his keys and wallet.
“It’s under my name, it’s already paid for,” Stebbins said as he opened his wallet to get it.
“You already paid? We said we’d pay for dinner.” Gary’s eyebrows furrowed.
Stebbins kissed his forehead where his eyebrows creased. “Go.”
“He thinks he’s a sugar daddy now,” Collie said with a smug look.
“Financial dominance really gets me going.” Stebbins smiled.
“Can I get drunk at this thing?” Gary asked as he sat with his knees pulled to his chest in Collie’s truck. It was so old that the front seat was one long bench instead of multiple different seats.
Collie reached over and touched Gary’s neck, squeezing it gently and pulling him closer. “You can do whatever you want forever as far as I’m concerned.”
Gary leaned against his body and nodded his head. “Gonna drink so much.”
Collie laughed as he drove. “You get horny when you drink.“
“Or you just love me more when I’m drunk, creep.”
Collie smiled. “Maybe.”
“Get me drunk and take advantage of me,” Gary whispered as he started to kiss Collie’s neck.
“I’m trying to drive here baby.”
Gary rolled his eyes and moved down. He looked down at his nails and picked out a piece of dirt from under one of them. “I kinda wanna get my nails done.” He said after a moment of looking at them, they had been long a long time and he had painted them before but he had never gotten them done professionally.
“You should.”
“Is it weird?”
“What, worried you’ll look gay?”
Gary shrugged. “What if they’re mean to me?”
“You think a bunch of old ladies who do nails are gonna be mean to you?”
“I don’t know.”
“Oh god, are you gonna make me go with you?”
“I’ll make Stebbins go.”
“Make him pay for them too he’ll love that.”
“Maybe he is my sugar daddy.” He smiled softly.
“You are pretty spoiled.”
“You don’t think it’s too girly?” Gary asked as they waited for the food.
It took Collie a minute to even realize what he meant. “No.”
“You won’t be ashamed?”
“That’s a stupid question.”
“What if I wore skirts?”
“Do you want to wear skirts?” Collie asked.
“No, not necessarily but that’s not the point.”
“You can wear, do, or be whatever you want, and I will still want to be with you,” Collie said, annoyed.
“Order 57!” They called up and Collie went up to grab their order.
Gary followed him, grabbing the rest of the large order as blush covered his face.
Once they were back in the car, with the pizza secure in the backseat. Gary leaned in and kissed Collie softly and slowly, a rare type of kiss for him to initiate first.
Collie smiled as Gary pulled away. “What was that for?”
Gary nuzzled his face. “I love you.”
Collie kissed his nose. “I love you too baby. Stop asking me stupid questions, makes me feel like you’re asking me if I’d love you if you were a worm.”
“Would you?”
Collie rolled his eyes and started the car. “We’ve got a party to host.”
“What do you think they’ll say?” Gary asked as they pulled into the driveway. He only saw Pete’s car so far, he wondered how the others were coming.
“I doubt there will be a big reaction, they’ll probs just be surprised and then move on.” Collie was carrying all the food so Gary could open the door for him.
Gary unlocked the house and held the door open for Collie. Once he was inside he shut the door and went looking to find Stebbins, already craving him after their short amount of time apart. He found him in the kitchen with Ray opening the fridge to grab him a cold water.
“Hey,” Ray said with a smile.
“Hi,” Gary said, wishing he had found Stebbins alone.
“Congrats on the new place?” Ray said awkwardly.
“I’m excited, felt like a good adjustment because Art is always up late and I tend to get up early.” Gary lied.
Collie walked into the kitchen and saved him. He put down the food and dapped up Ray. “Hey, man where’s Pete?”
“He’s outside!”
“I think the beers outside too,” Collie said and Ray nodded and followed him out into the backyard as they talked.
“You okay?” Stebbins asked as he wrapped his arms around both sides of Gary and cornered him against the counter.
Gary before he leaned in for a kiss. “Will you take me to get my nails done this week?”
Stebbins smiled. “I have work baby.”
“After?”
Stebbins nodded as he held his face against Gary’s soft cheek. “Okay.”
Gary kissed him again, one more for good luck.
“Did you leave the door unlocked?”
Gary nodded.
“C’mon let’s go outside, text the others that the door is unlocked.”
Gary took out his phone and texted them before walking outside after Stebbins. He grabbed himself a seltzer from the ice chest and found a spot on the comfortable outdoor couch next to where Collie was sitting and felt an overwhelming urge to curl up next to him. He remembered he was supposed to hate him but felt no desire to keep up that charade. Stebbins sat on the other side of him and he felt better.
Eventually, the other guys pulled up and everyone ate. Gary didn’t have much of an appetite. He didn’t really like pizza. He had already eaten a big lunch and preferred continuing to drink over eating something else. Luckily for him when Stebbins came back he sat even closer to him, close enough to where their bodies were basically touching. Collie moved closer after going to get them more drinks.
They talked about all sorts of things, Pete and Ray’s new place, Harkness’s new job, Hank sleeping with what he called a perfect ten even though Art said she was a seven at best, and finally Collie said something.
“I’ve got some news too.” He said after a moment of silence and he looked to Stebbins who nodded in encouragement.
“What’s up, man?” Ray asked.
“I uh, I moved in here too.”
“Here, here?” Hank asked.
“I thought you only had two bedrooms?” Harkness said to Stebbins.
“Yeah, there are only two. We’ll only be using one.”
“Wait what?” Pete asked, and they all looked shocked.
“No shit?” Ray asked.
“Like a bunk bed situation?” Hank asked.
Gary covered his face with his hands. He laughed loudly.
“What grown men would share bunk beds?” Collie asked.
“I’d share bunk beds before I shared my man,” Pete said with a laugh.
“We’re not sharing him. We’re together.” Stebbins said softly. “All of us.”
“That’s some freaky shit.” Art said with a laugh.
“Ah, I don’t even wanna think about how that works.” Hank added.
“And I thought Ray and Pete were gay.”
“We are gay?” Pete said with a laugh.
“Are you happy?” Ray asked.
The three of them nodded.
“It works for us,” Stebbins said.
“Anyone else more shocked by how Collie and Gary don’t kill each other?” Art asked.
“Yeah, you two are supposed to hate each other!” Hank said.
“Oh, I always thought that was sexual tension,” Pete said.
Ray laughed. “How long has this been going on?”
“Dating or fucking?” Collie asked.
Gary’s ears turned red.
Stebbins laughed.
“Oh, they’re serious.” Pete said.
“We’ve been dating a little over a year,” Stebbins said.
Gary nodded. He felt like he was struggling to breathe until he felt Stebbins place his hand in his hair and pull him closer. He relaxed completely once he could lay his head against Stebbins’ side. He felt Collie’s hand on his thigh and finally felt okay.
“That is crazy,” Ray said with a smile.
“So now you three are the only single ones,” Pete said to the others.
“We’re practically a couples group.”
“Maybe y’all should just go gay,” Gary said with a laugh.
“Hank I really think you could adapt.” Ray teased.
“Fuck no. Ladies only for me man. I’m not taking the easy way out.”
They all laughed.
“How is it easier to be gay moron?” Collie asked.
“Look if you all can do it I’m sure it’s pretty easy.”
Gary laughed.
As the night went on everything started to feel normal again. After a while, Stebbins whispered in Gary’s ear. “You okay?”
Gary nodded sleepily.
Stebbins kissed the top of his head, no longer caring if anyone saw.
Hank, Harkness, and Art left first because Art was their ride and it was late.
Pete and Ray stayed longer.
With the pressure of not seeming too affectionate around their straight friends, they found themselves relaxing a bit more.
Gary moved to lean against Collie and Stebbins pulled his legs over his lap. Gary smiled as Collie held him.
Pete and Ray weren’t much better. Pete eventually ended up on his back lying down with his head on Ray’s lap as they talked about all sorts of things.
“We should go on double dates or something,” Pete said drunkenly as Ray laughed from above him.
“Doing what?” Collie asked.
“I don’t know, some gay shit.” Pete laughed.
“He’s a drunk planner, ignore him.”
Pete rolled his eyes. “My husband hates me.”
“Not your husband.” Ray said.
Pete muttered something under his breath.
“What was that?” Ray asked.
Pete smiled. “Nothing honey.”
“You know I’m your ride, right?” Ray asked cutely.
“In my car.”
“That you are in no shape to drive, I could leave your drunk ass here.”
“Please don’t,” Gary said immediately.
“Yeah, you’ll get him back scarred.” Collie said.
“Like a dog from the pound.” Stebbins added.
Pete sat up and drank the rest of his beer then got really close to Ray’s lips. “Can I come home with you?” He begged. “Please.”
“I hate you,” Ray said, pushing him away with a smile. “You’re the worst when you drink.”
Pete leaned in and started to kiss Ray’s neck.
Ray tried to push him off of him. “I think that means it’s time to go home. He’s really excited about the new apartment.” Ray blushed.
“Excited to christen it,” Pete said not so quietly.
“I’ll walk you out,” Stebbins said.
“Night, night,” Pete said cutely.
“Night buddy,” Collie said.
Gary waved.
“Night guys. Thanks for hosting.”
“Night,” Gary said.
As soon as they walked away Gary sighed and immediately relaxed completely into Collie’s arms.
“Long night huh?” Collie asked.
Gary nodded. He didn’t have to ask for what he wanted, because Collie immediately knew.
Collie leaned down and kissed him sweetly. “Are you too tired for it tonight?” He asked.
Gary whined and shook his head. “You think those walls are tall enough for us to fuck outside?” He asked with a smile.
Collie laughed.
“That’s a two-story house baby.”
“We’re not having sex outside,” Stebbins said as he came up to them. “Want me to carry you up?” Gary looked up at him and nodded. Collie pushed him out of his lap and Gary stood up and jumped into Stebbins’s arms.
“You deserve to be fucked in a bed whenever that’s possible,” Stebbins said as they made their way upstairs.
“I love you,” Gary said happily against Stebbins neck.
“I love you too sweetheart.” Stebbins climbed onto their bed comfortably and lay Gary down onto it. “So what’s this about getting your nails done?”
“He told you about that already?” Collie asked as he unbuckled his jeans and started to take them off.
“Yeah, said he wants me to take him this week… told him I have work and he said after.”
Collie laughed.
“You wanna look pretty, is that it?” Stebbins asked as he climbed over him.
Gary nodded as he wrapped his arms around his neck. “And I want you to come with me…”
“Yeah? Why me baby?”
“I want you to drive me.” Gary kissed Stebbins' lips. “And pick out the color.” He kissed him again. “And pay.” He repeated the kiss.
“Yeah?” Stebbins whispered.
“You wanna be my sugar daddy?” Gary whispered.
Stebbins let out a careful breath as he nodded his head. “I’ll give you anything you want baby.”
“I want you,” Gary whispered.
Stebbins fell into another kiss, attacking Gary’s lips with his as he started to tear their clothes off. “I didn’t think you could get any fucking sexier, and you do.”
Everything but Collie and Stebbins’s boxers were quickly discarded and Gary lay on the bed with Collie’s lips between his as Stebbins’ fingers pushed him aside.
“Just go in…” Gary whined.
“No one’s fucked you since last night. Let him.” Collie said softly as he rubbed Gary’s hip. “Let it feel good.”
“I like when it hurts.”
“I don’t wanna hurt you.” Stebbins said.
“Take what you’re given.” Collie said as he kissed him. “You want both of us tonight?”
Gary nodded.
“Then we’re taking this slow.”
“Why don’t you tell us what else you wanna try?” Stebbins asked as he pushed his fingers deeper inside him and kissed the inside of his leg. “You want your nails to look pretty, what else?”
“He was asking me if I’d love him if he wore skirts.” Collie teased as he wrapped a hand around Gary’s hard-on.
“Is that right?”
“Said I didn’t want to.” Gary whined feeling himself slip into his submission.
“What if it was just for us baby?” Collie asked softly. “You wouldn’t if we asked you to?”
Gary bit his lip slightly. He felt torn.
“What if I took you shopping and bought you something nice and pretty baby?”
Stebbins pushed his fingers deeper inside him, stretching him out a bit more until he felt like it wouldn’t hurt for him to take more.
“Like what?” Gary asked softly.
Stebbins pulled his fingers out of him.
Gary let out a quiet whine.
“Shhh baby, I’m right here.” Stebbins whispered as he started to push back inside him.
Gary let out a quiet noise.
Stebbins pushed Gary’s knees up and to the side as he took him. “Buy you all kinds of things, sweetheart. Come home from work with some pretty panties…” Stebbins whispered, leaning down to kiss Gary as he started to move inside him.
Gary whimpered.
“Would you wear them, baby?” Stebbins asked.
When Stebbins pulled away from Gary’s lips Collie replaced him but Gary still managed to nod.
“Yeah? Want me to buy you pretty little clothes princess?” Stebbins asked.
Gary whined as he nodded his head, his cock leaked precum against his stomach.
“Oh, he likes that…” Collie purred against his neck as he wrapped his hand back around Gary’s cock. “You like that baby girl?”
Gary whimpered and shook his head.
“What’s the matter, sweetheart? Scared of how good it feels?” Stebbins asked as he fucked him deeper.
Gary nodded.
“You know what to say if you want us to stop, right baby?” Collie asked.
Gary nodded.
“You okay if we keep going then… you wanna be a good girl for us?”
Gary teared up as he nodded his head.
Collie smiled and kissed him again, pushing away his tears.
Stebbins moved back over him and kept kissing him as he thrust deeper inside him. “You’re so beautiful baby. Such a good girl.”
Gary whimpered, shaking underneath Stebbins, and finishing all over his own stomach as they kissed. “Please.” He begged, scraping his nails into Stebbins’s strong back.
“Want me to cum inside you, sweetheart?”
“Please.” Gary cried as he clung to him.
Stebbins couldn’t last any longer before he shot his load inside him.
Stebbins lay there over Gary with his arms supporting his body as he caught his breath, he placed gentle kisses all over Gary’s chest. “I love you so much.” He whispered.
One of Collie’s hands rubbed Stebbins's back and the other ran its fingers through Gary’s hair.
“Feel so good,” Gary whispered.
“Is that enough for tonight? Or do you want more baby?” Collie asked. “I won’t be mad, it’s been a long day.”
“Want you,” Gary whispered. “Want both of you, always.”
Stebbins smiled.
“You have me baby, doesn’t mean I need to be inside you right now… I know you’re probably sore.”
“Please,” Gary begged.
“Okay.”
“You ready for me to pull out baby?” Stebbins asked.
“Roll me over first,” Gary said.
Stebbins listened, he carefully pushed deeper inside him and rolled them over so he was lying on his back and Gary was on top of him.
He looked over his shoulder at Collie. “Will you fuck me like this?” He batted his eyes sweetly.
Collie bit his lip and nodded his head. “However you want it sweetheart.”
“Mkay, you can pull out.” Gary said softly.
Stebbins placed his hands on Gary’s hips and carefully pulled out of him before wrapping his arms around him to hold him in place with his legs spread.
Collie positioned himself behind them and carefully pushed inside Gary.
Gary made a quiet happy noise as he felt full again.
“Fuck I swear you feel extra good tonight baby.” Collie praised. “Think I’m gonna have to go shopping for you too… get something that fits this perfect ass.” Collie squeezed the sides of Gary’s ass tightly. “I might have to take a few measurements first, is that okay princess?”
“I-I’ll wear whatever you want me to.” Gary whimpered.
“Anything?” Stebbins asked quietly.
“What about a butt plug?” Collie asked, so we don’t have to go through all this work of opening you up every time.
Gary moaned loudly. “Fuck, oh fuck. Yes. Please, Col.”
“Bet you’d love that wouldn’t you. Taking it out to fill you up every morning and every night. Forcing you to stay full of our cum.”
Gary was almost completely out of breath. “Please.” He cried.
“Fucking hell, tell me you want it.”
“I want you to keep me full all the time.” Gary begged.
Collie lost it he gave him exactly what he wanted and pushed all the way inside of him when he was done. Collie leaned over him and kissed his back. “Wanna shower princess?” He asked gently.
“Bath,” Gary asked quietly as they held him.
“Can I pull out?”
“Mhm.”
Collie carefully did.
“Carry me?” Gary asked.
Stebbins nodded. “I’ve got you, baby.”
Gary relaxed completely and let them take over. It was wonderful. For how much he enjoyed sex, he enjoyed the aftercare almost as much.
Collie ran them a bath, in the huge master tub and waited until it was full to tell Stebbins.
When it was ready Stebbins picked Gary up and easily carried him into the bathroom and helped him get into the tub. Once he was in the warm water Gary still held onto Stebbins.
“You did so good baby.” Stebbins whispered.
“Feel good,” Gary said softly.
“We love you so much princess.”
Gary whined at the nickname and covered his face.
“Is it embarrassing?” Collie asked him as he got in with them.
Gary nodded.
“Why?”
“It’s so girly…”
“So?” Stebbins asked. “What’s wrong with girly?”
“I‘m not a girl.”
“Baby you can be whatever you want. Just because you like girly things doesn’t mean you’re a girl. Who cares?” Stebbins said.
Gary pouted. “I’m tired.”
“We can talk about it more tomorrow, why don’t you relax and let us get you cleaned up okay?” Collie said as he placed a kiss against Gary’s bare shoulder.
“Okay..”
“Good.”
“Love you.” Gary said.
“We love you too baby.”