1 - 20 of 150 Works in Erin Greene (Midnight Mass)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Most Glorious and Holy Light, Bow Before Unending Night by OmbreSuit
Fandoms: Midnight Mass (TV)
20 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
It's spring on Crockett Island, and you find Father Paul Hill has got his eye on you.
-
Tags
Summary
AU of Series - What if Riley had fled Crockett Island at the end of Episode 5? Struggling to come to terms with the change Pruitt insists he "accept", Riley initially finds himself in serious trouble on the mainland though his salvation comes in the form of a blue eyed, brunette willing to help him navigate this drastic change yet isn't afraid of what he is. What happens when he finds his footing and makes his way back to Crockett with his new companion? More importantly, how does a certain raven haired priest react to the return of a changed Riley and the arrival of this stranger?
Title taken from the Joe Cocker song.
Series
- Part 1 of Gods and Demons
-
Tags
Summary
Hassan has to solve Crockett Island's latest mystery while battling the forces of Bev Keane and the worst cold he's ever had.
-
Tags
Summary
Gemma finds the new priest exciting and charming, and he seems to have some interest in her. How much, though? More than she first expected. Things escalate and take an unexpected turn, and soon they find them in a situation where there's nobody to ask for advice, other than your own heart and wit. What does it mean to know somebody? To love them? To figure out right and wrong when things are not what they seem to be?
NOTE: this work diverges from canon as I have eliminated the connection between Father Paul Hill | Monsignor John Pruitt and Mildred and Sarah Gunning, and that I have changed the ending - the island wasn't destroyed, but they get stuck in a somewhat sucky situation still.
-
Tags
Summary
After the death of her beloved Aunt Anette, Jessica Farrow must travel to remote Crockett Island to care for her cousin. But when many mysterious unknowns begin to question the girl's square thinking, it is when between deaths, faith, questions, strange occurrences, explanations that try to be logical and marks from the past... Apparently there is something else.
"Carry my soul into the night, may the stars light my way. I glory in the sight as darkness takes the day."
-Nicholas Hooper (In Noctem) -
Tags
Summary
Father Paul is going through it after everything that happened in the Holy Land, and you are his confessional. You are a quietly grieving soul drawn to Crockett Island in search of meaning, healing, and something unnamed.
This story follows the events of the show. -
Tags
Summary
You're a young recent college graduate, but news of your mother's passing has sent you back to Crockett Island. The suffocating religious presence reminds you of why you left in the first place, but it seems someone new has joined the church.
===
Skip to Chapter 3 if you only want to read the freaky stuff
====
This is probably just going to be a rewrite of the show but from the perspective of the reader as an insert, with main focus being on Father Paul and the...other things that come with him ;)
-2nd person pov (ex. "You do this and that.")
-subjective narrator
-your character is a trans man in his late twenties
-I have no clue what I am doing -
Tags
Summary
There's a rumor going around that Father Paul is canoodling with one of the islanders. John confronts the islander he is indeed canoodling with, and, well, he just can't help himself.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1,322
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 9
- Hits:
- 84
-
Tags
Summary
With your grandfather's passing, you have been tasked with cleaning out his house in your hometown on Crockett Island. If the grief and frustration isn't enough, things take a turn for the strange when you meet the awkward and charming interim priest of your old parish. Leave it to you to get tangled in a complicated romance and all of the fallout that comes with sticking your nose into places it shouldn't be. Peace is too much to ask for these days.
-
Tags
Summary
After a mysterious new priest arrives on Crockett Island, a tight-knit Catholic community, they experience a "spiritual" journey that will leave them altered in ways they could never have imagined. After years of being reduced to a wheelchair and paralyzed, a girl is able to take steps, people of old age are able to do things they haven't been able to do for decades... But what is the cost of all of these miraculous modifications to such a ghost of an island? But what has to be paid, as nothing good is ever given away free of any equal reaction.
-
Tags
Summary
Feels good to be back on Crockett Island... or does it? It's under unfortunate circumstances that you're back, but you're more than willing to become a part of the ecosystem on the island and reintroduce yourself to everyone on it, they haven't seen your face (or any new ones for that matter) in a veryyy long time. That is until you're graced with an ill-fated visit by what Monsignor Pruitt thinks is an angel, and what you're convinced is a vampire. It seems you're cursed to constantly butt-heads with Pruitt, while simultaneously being blessed that there's another person in town that understands how you feel and what you're going through with the... angel, no. Vampire. This confusing and unique relationship with Pruitt leads down a winding road, a push and pull in-between you two, and digging into a hole that you can only dig so deep with him, but he's willing to dig it with you. >:^)
-
The Second Opinion Sucked, I Need a Third Opinion by Red Eyes Black Scythe (VisceraNight)
Fandoms: Midnight Mass (TV), House M.D.
30 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Erin Greene continues to seek a diagnosis for her mysteriously disappearing fetus, which leads her to the Princeton-Plainsboro Teaching Hospital where she is examined by Dr. House and his team.
-
Tags
Summary
After the events of "The Autobiography of Mildred Gunning" (which you do not have to read to enjoy this fic, but I personally recommend it because, well, I wrote it), Sarah mourns the death of her mother and struggles with getting lost in thought. She must keep her appointments, however, and they end up some of the little human interaction she has.
Series
- Part 2 of Midnight Mass AU
-
Thirst Trap by LittleRedRidingCat for All My Beautiful Stone Cold Weirdos and Father Meow Meow Lovers
Fandoms: Midnight Mass (TV)
18 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
It’s a goddamn humdinger of a disaster, and it’s absolutely not your fault.
It’s not.
It’s Erin’s fault, and you’ll go to your grave saying it.
She got you into that fucking church. She encouraged you to “use it as an opportunity.” Yeah, you’re never going to let her forget this as long as you’re both breathing.For now, all you can do is stare at the last page in what is the third basic black-and-white composition notebook you’d managed to fill during your time on Crockett. Your pulse picks up, and you hope it means you’re going to have a major coronary episode that ends your life because right now, it seems easier to die than to show your face in the general store, the small Co-Op, or St. Pat’s – especially St. Pat’s – ever again.
“Fuck. I’m toast,” you think.
Sometimes, a writer just needs a little divine inspiration.
When you find yourself trying to eek out a new novel for Bold Stroke Books (and, yes, you write *those* novels) Erin takes you to church. It's a strange move that doesn't make much sense - until you see the new priest.
He might not save your soul, but he could be the key to saving your career. -
In A Communion of Saints, Let’s Be Sinners by nashvillest213
Fandoms: Midnight Mass (TV)
16 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Come along on a journey to Crockett Island, where nothing is as it seems. A burnt-out writer arrives, seeking solitude to finish her next book.
That’s not going to happen though.
Father Paul Hill knows instantly that she is his, the Lord God’s Divine Plan laid out in flesh.
Before the New Sacrament, he would have balked at these kinds of feelings, the idea of breaking his vows. But now, his Angel has shown him that through God all things are possible.
-
Tags
Summary
“You were there, on that lake with me.”
“What happens after?”
“I don’t know.”
“What happens when you die?”
What happens?
Riley is going to die. Erin can't let that happen.
-
None of These Words Are in the Bible by Red Eyes Black Scythe (VisceraNight)
Fandoms: Midnight Mass (TV)
15 Nov 2024
Tags
Summary
In an AU where Riley died in the car crash, Beverly feels like Erin came back to Crockett Island specifically just to annoy her. But when someone even more annoying (Father Paul) shows up, the two women soon become close to each other.
-
Tags
Summary
Your father has passed, and you are given an ultimatum. Go to Saint Patrick's, find God. In your quest, you find someone else. A newcomer, a priest. He offers to show you the path of righteousness, but you are more interested in the path to him.
-
Tags
Summary
Millie and Father Paul’s conversation in the church take a different turn, when Mildred decides to play pretend and he gets his chance to gain what he always wanted - only there’s some variables he never accounted for in his fantasies: Sarah and Bev and how he'd get out of his own mess.
-
you have tasted love and it tasted sweet, you drank the blood and bit the meat by laylaelfaoulylover
Fandoms: Midnight Mass (TV)
12 Aug 2024
Tags
Summary
You thought you had escaped the church when you left home. The new priest on Crockett keeps bringing it to your doorstep.